Fall Bourbon Pairing Guide: Which Bourbon Goes With Every Wood-Fired Cut at NANDO in Evansville

When the evenings turn crisp in Evansville, there’s something about a wood-fired steak and a good bourbon that just feels right. Both bring bold flavor, warmth, and a touch of smoke, and when they’re paired well, each makes the other better.

At NANDO Wood-Fired Steak & Seafood on Main Street, our kitchen is rooted in flame. As our About page puts it, “every element touches the flame.” Our bar pours a lineup of bourbons that’s made for exactly this kind of meal.

Here’s our fall guide to pairing bourbon with every wood-fired cut on our menu, plus a few cocktails and zero-proof options worth trying.

The Basics: What Makes Bourbon, Bourbon?

Under federal standards (27 CFR § 5.143), bourbon is made from a fermented mash of at least 51% corn, distilled at 160 proof or less, and stored in charred new oak barrels at 125 proof or less. That charred oak is where many of bourbon’s signature caramel, vanilla, and toasted notes come from, and why it pairs so naturally with fire-kissed steak.

New to bourbon? Start with our Beginner’s Guide to Bourbon.

The Golden Rule of Pairing: Balance

As we explain in How to Pair Whiskey With Steak, the key is balance:

  • Lighter, leaner cuts pair best with softer, smoother pours.
  • Heavily marbled cuts can stand up to fuller-bodied or higher-proof whiskey.
  • When in doubt, start with bourbon for its smoother sweetness.

Our Fall Pairings, Cut by Cut

Bourbon availability can change, so ask your server or our bar team for tonight’s lineup and their recommendations.

Filet Mignon (8 oz)

Our filet is tender and lean, so it calls for a pour that won’t overpower it. Look for a softer, balanced, lower-proof bourbon.

Try it with: Ask our bar team for a smooth, lower-proof pour from tonight’s lineup.

NY Strip (16 oz)

The strip has a bit more chew and a beefier flavor than the filet. A balanced pour with caramel, oak, and moderate spice is a great match.

Try it with: Four Roses Single Barrel

Ribeye (14 oz, 45-Day Dry-Aged)

Rich marbling plus the deep flavor of 45 days of dry-aging make this one of the boldest cuts on our menu. It can handle a fuller bourbon with noticeable oak, spice, or toasted sweetness. A double-oaked or longer-aged pour is a natural fit.

Try it with: Woodford Reserve Double Oak or Russell’s Single Barrel

Black Angus Sirloin (10 oz)

A hearty, approachable cut with classic steakhouse flavor. Pair it with a pour that brings warm, toasted notes to echo the char from the fire.

Try it with: Elijah Craig Toasted

A5 Wagyu (Boneless Ribeye, Filet Mignon, or NY Strip)

A5 Wagyu is incredibly rich, so less is more. Our pairing guidance suggests a smaller pour sipped slowly, with a balanced bourbon rather than a very high-proof one, or a balanced cocktail. Going all in? Our Flight of All A5 Wagyu includes 4 oz each of the A5 Boneless Ribeye, Filet Mignon, and NY Strip.

Try it with: Vintage Proof ($18), with Buffalo Trace stirred with house-crafted orange syrup and maraschino liqueur.

Learn more in The Difference Between Prime, Choice, and Wagyu Beef.

Woodfire Pueblo 1/2 Chicken

Dry-brined with smoked spices and served with salsa verde and an herb salad, this lighter wood-fired dish pairs well with a smooth, easy-drinking pour.

Try it with: Ask our bar team for a smooth, easy-drinking pour from tonight’s lineup.

Bourbon Cocktails for Fall

  • New Fashioned ($22): RD1 Amburana Bourbon, vanilla syrup, tobacco bitters, and amaro in a modern riff on the Old Fashioned. Earthy, warm, and complex.
  • Vintage Proof ($18): Buffalo Trace with house-crafted orange syrup and maraschino liqueur. Bittersweet, bold, and aromatic.
  • WhistlePig Smoked Old Fashioned ($25): WhistlePig 6 Year Rye, demerara sugar, and Angostura and orange bitters. A smoky choice for a dry-aged cut.

For an After-Dinner Pour

Finish the night with Starlight Cigar Batch, or ask our bar team for a recommendation to go with dessert. Our bourbon guide suggests looking for vanilla, caramel, nut, chocolate, or dark-fruit notes to pair with something sweet.

Not Drinking Tonight?

Our zero-proof whiskey drinks still bring the warmth:

  • Ginger & Oak ($11): N/A whiskey, lime, and ginger ale.
  • Espresso Notini ($11): N/A whiskey, house-made cold brew, and vanilla syrup.

Make a Reservation

Explore our full menu and drinks list, then join us at 415 Main St in Downtown Evansville. Planning a group dinner? Our private dining rooms offer custom wood-fired menus and optional bourbon flights. Call (812) 777-0177 or book a table.

‍

What bourbon goes best with a ribeye?

What should I drink with filet mignon?

Can you pair bourbon with Wagyu?

What makes bourbon different from other whiskey?

Do you offer bourbon flights?

Do you have non-alcoholic options?

Reservations

book a table at nando steakhouse in evansville

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.